My Tax Preparer Charged Too Much: How To Avoid This

Someone is opening their empty wallet.

My Tax Preparer Charged Too Much: How To Avoid This

Tax season often comes with its share of stress, but finding out that your tax preparer has charged more than expected can add an extra layer of concern. In an era where the complexities of tax laws meet the convenience of virtual tax preparation services, navigating the realm of fees can be challenging. You may not even notice when you’re being overcharged!

If you’ve ever found yourself wondering, “My tax preparer charged too much – what do I do?” this guide by Simplicity Financial is here to provide insights and actionable steps to address the situation. From understanding industry standards to exploring avenues for clarification, we’ll walk you through the necessary considerations to ensure a fair and transparent resolution when you believe you’ve been overcharged by your tax preparer.

Do This If Your Tax Preparer Charged Too Much

If you believe your tax preparer has overcharged you, there are several steps you can take to address the situation:

  1. Discuss the Issue: The first step is to discuss the issue with your tax preparer. It’s possible that there was a misunderstanding or an error in the billing process. By communicating your concerns, you may be able to resolve the issue amicably.
  2. Request an Explanation: Ask your tax preparer for a detailed breakdown of the fees charged. Understanding the services provided and the associated costs can help clarify whether the charges were appropriate.
  3. File a Complaint: If you are unable to resolve the issue directly with your tax preparer, you can file a complaint with the appropriate authorities. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) provides a form, Form 14157, for reporting improper tax preparation practices. This form allows you to document your concerns and submit them for review.
  4. Seek Legal Advice: If the overcharging appears to be intentional or if you believe you have been a victim of fraud, you may want to seek legal advice. A legal professional can help you understand your rights and options for recourse.
  5. Find a New Preparer: If you’re dissatisfied with your current tax preparer, consider finding a new one for future tax filings. Look for a reputable and trustworthy professional to ensure accurate and fair service.

It’s important to proactively address overcharging by a tax preparer to protect your financial interests and ensure compliance with tax regulations.

How Much Can A Tax Preparer Charge Legally

Someone is counting cash in their hands.

Knowing how much a tax preparer can charge is crucial. Their fees must be reasonable and reflect the return’s complexity. Tax preparers have some leeway in setting their rates, but they must charge fees that are fair and consistent with industry standards. Taxpayers should refer to the CPA fee schedule to assess reasonable charges. They should also discuss fees upfront to avoid surprises later on.

At Simplicity Financial, we believe that transparency is vital. We offer tax preparation services for businesses and individuals, always beginning our services with a consultation. This ensures our clients feel informed and comfortable, regardless of their prior accounting knowledge.

How Do Tax Preparers Collect Fees

A long bill is coming out of a POS machine.

Tax preparers employ various methods for fee collection based on their business models and client preferences. Here are some common approaches:

1. Flat Fee:

  • How it Works: Tax preparers charge a fixed, predetermined amount for their services, regardless of the time spent or complexity of the tax return.
  • Advantages: Provides transparency, as clients know upfront the cost of the service.
  • Considerations: Clients should clarify what services are included in the flat fee to avoid surprises.

2. Hourly Rate:

  • How it Works: Tax preparers charge clients based on the hours spent working on their tax returns.
  • Advantages: Reflects the actual time and effort expended on a client’s specific tax situation.
  • Considerations: Clients should understand how hours are tracked, whether in increments, and if there’s a rounding policy.

3. Tiered Pricing:

  • How it Works: Tax preparers offer different service levels or charge varying fees based on the complexity of the tax return.
  • Advantages: Allows flexibility to accommodate different client needs and situations.
  • Considerations: Clients should know what each tier includes and select the one that aligns with their requirements.

4. Combination Model:

  • How it Works: Tax preparers charge a base fee for standard services and additional fees for extra services, such as itemizing deductions or advising on complex financial matters.
  • Advantages: Offers flexibility in catering to various client needs while ensuring fair compensation for additional work.
  • Considerations: Clients should clearly understand what the base fee covers and be aware of potential additional charges.

5. Upfront Payment:

  • How it Works: Many tax preparers collect their fees upfront before commencing work on the tax return.
  • Advantages: Ensures the tax preparer is compensated for their time, regardless of the final tax outcome.
  • Considerations: Clients should clarify when and how payment is expected, whether at the beginning or upon completion of the tax return.
  • Note: it is advised by the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation that you ask for the full fee to be calculated before any services are performed.

6. Payment at Filing:

  • How it Works: Tax preparers collect their fees at the time of filing, once the tax return is completed and submitted.
  • Advantages: Directly correlates payment with completing the task, providing clarity for both parties.
  • Considerations: Clients should understand the specific terms and conditions related to payment at filing.

7. Installment Options:

  • How it Works: Some tax preparers may offer clients the option to pay fees over a period of time rather than in one lump sum.
  • Advantages: Provides flexibility for clients with budget constraints.
  • Considerations: Clients should inquire about any interest or additional charges associated with installment options.

It’s essential for clients to have open communication with their tax preparers regarding fees before engaging their services. Clear discussions about fee structures, payment terms, and expectations help ensure a transparent and mutually satisfactory financial arrangement.

How Does The CPA Fee Schedule Work

Stacks of files on a desk.

The fee schedule for Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) can vary based on several factors, including the complexity of the tax return, the location, the preparer’s experience, and the billing method. This schedule is influenced by the tax return’s complexity, preparation time, and the CPA’s qualifications. 

While each preparer has a unique fee structure, common elements are considered, such as flat fees for straightforward returns and hourly rates, where charges depend on preparation time. Some CPAs adopt tiered pricing based on income levels or return complexity. Although there are guidelines on legal charges set by professional bodies, they are ethical standards, not legally binding. 

Researching local rates and comparing them with the services provided helps assess the reasonableness of your tax preparer’s fees. Understanding this fee schedule is crucial for determining whether the charges align with industry norms, and facilitating informed discussions if further clarification is needed.

When Do Tax Preparers Get Paid

Tax preparers and their clients typically agree on the payment schedule in advance, with some preparers charging fees upfront, and most collecting fees at the time of filing. Some preparers may offer installment options, and it’s crucial for taxpayers to understand the payment terms to avoid confusion or disputes. Reviewing invoices and fee schedules can help individuals ensure the charges are fair and within legal limits.

Questions To Ask Your Accountant or Tax Preparer

Two business women are talking in an office while pointing at a computer.

Before hiring an accountant or tax preparer, asking the right questions can help avoid being overcharged. Here are some key questions to consider:

  • What’s your tax background? Understanding the preparer’s experience and expertise can provide insight into their qualifications.
  • How do you charge clients? Inquiring about the fee structure and how fees are determined can help you understand the cost of the services.
  • How do you file taxes? Knowing the filing method used by the preparer, such as e-filing or mailing, can impact the efficiency of the process.
  • What is your availability year-round? Ensuring that the preparer is available beyond tax filing season is essential for addressing post-filing inquiries or needs.

You can review more questions to ask a tax preparer, along with insightful tips and a glossary for beginners, in this booklet by the Illinois CPA Society. By asking these questions, you can make an informed decision when selecting an accountant or tax preparer and reduce the risk of overcharging.

Final Notes on Virtual Tax Preparation

A notebook is open on a desk with some coins and money splayed across.

To avoid being overcharged for tax preparation services, stay informed and ask your accountant or tax preparer about their billing methods and payment policies. Familiarize yourself with the CPA fee schedule to ensure you’re paying reasonable fees. If you suspect you’ve been overcharged, ask for an itemized breakdown of charges, consult credible sources to compare fees, and bring up any discrepancies with your tax preparer. Remember to remain vigilant and address concerns promptly to find a trustworthy tax preparer who offers fair prices.

When it comes to dealing with taxes, having the right knowledge can help protect you from being overcharged. It’s important to stay informed and take proactive steps to safeguard your financial interests and ensure compliance with tax regulations. If you’re looking for dependable and transparent tax services, consider contacting Simplicity Financial for assistance. Contact us today to experience hassle-free and fairly priced tax preparation services.


The information provided in this blog post is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be, nor should it be construed as, legal, financial, or tax advice. Tax laws and regulations are complex and subject to change; you should consult with a professional tax advisor, financial planner, or attorney for advice specific to your individual circumstances. The author and Simplicity Financial disclaim any liability for any errors or omissions in the information provided or for any actions taken in reliance on this information.